The Reckoner!

Leonardo DiCaprio as Gatsby?

Yup, that's who's playing him in Baz Luhrmann's new version with Toby McGuire as Nick and Carey Mulligan as Daisy. So, would Leonardo be your choice for this icon role?

Reckoning Results!
WINNER!
YES
NO
Green light
Civilization to pieces
65.5%
(19)
34.5%
(10)
Previous Reckoning!
PREVIOUS!
The Dark Knight Rises! Will Christopher Nolan dare kill off Batman at the end?
Next Reckoning!
NEXT!
Gamer Reckoning: RPG's - East Vs. West


Reckoning Comments!

I don't recall squinting being a huge part of the Gatsby character, so I'm not sure if this is in DiCaprio's wheelhouse.  That is, unless the light on the end of Daisy's dock is really, really bright.


You know where I stand on this issue. DiCaprio could play an armchair and still be great in my book. Gatsby will be truly THE GREAT!

 


Come on, Leonardo DiFrickingCaprio?


I think DiCaprio would make a great Gatsby!  I also very much agree with Aunt Linda;)

 


Sorry but DiCaprio plays the same person in every movie he is in. Honestly he has good presence on the screen and I enjoy his films, but IMO is always himself. Not a GREAT actor.


I like DiCaprio, but he doesn't have the mystery or charisma for this part. How about Edward Norton or even Ryan Gossling?

 


Well...the people have spoken. And they want more Leo


The Reckoner!